2018-07-05 | Arizona Desert Walker Joy A. Collura and contributing other Douglas Fir
Views expressed to "the public at large” and "of public concern"
DISCLAIMER: Please fully read the front page of the website (link below) before reading any of the posts ( www.yarnellhillfirerevelations.com )
The authors and the blog are not responsible for misuse, reuse, recycled and cited and/or uncited copies of content within this blog by others. The content even though we are presenting it public if being reused must get written permission in doing so due to copyrighted material. Thank you.
Abbreviations used below: Wildland Firefighters (WFs) - Firefighters (FFs).
For it is not an enemy who reproaches me, Then I could bear it; Nor is it one who hates me who has exalted himself against me, Then I could hide myself from him. But it is you, a man my equal, My companion and my familiar friend ... Psalms 55:12-14 (NASB)
ALL Wildland Firefighters (WFs) are to follow the standards, guidelines, and principles contained within the Inter-agency Standards for Fire and Fire Aviation Operations, (link provided) otherwise known as the Red Book. Below, I will address the following key Red Book chapters dealing with (1) Fire Leadership; (2) Safety and Risk Management and their Guiding Principles and Goal; and (3) Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and Required Fireline PPE. I cite from the respective sources immediately below and delve into these important subject areas further.
"Chapter 1 - Fire Leadership
"Leadership is the art of influencing people in order to achieve a result. The most essential element for success in the wildland fire service is good leadership. Good leaders provide purpose, direction, and motivation for wildland firefighters working to accomplish difficult tasks under dangerous, stressful circumstances. Leaders often face difficult problems to which there are no simple, clear-cut, by-the-book solutions. In these situations, leaders must use their knowledge, skill, experience, education, values, and judgment to make decisions and to take or direct action- in short, to provide leadership. All firefighters, regardless of position, must provide leadership." (emphasis added)
"Chapter 7 - Safety and Risk Management
"Firefighter and public safety is our first priority. ... Every supervisor, employee, and volunteer is responsible for following safe work practices and procedures, as well as identifying and reporting unsafe conditions." (emphasis added)
"Guiding Principles
"These principles guide our fundamental wildland fire management practices,behaviors, and customs, and are mutually understood at every level of command. They include Risk Management, Standard Firefighting Orders and Watch Out Situations, LCES and the Downhill Line Construction Checklist. These principles are fundamental to how we perform fire operations, and are intended to improve decision making and firefighter safety. They are not absolute rules. They require judgment in application." (emphasis added)
"Goal
"The goal of the fire safety program is to provide direction and guidance for safe and effective management in all activities. Safety is the responsibility of everyone assigned to wildland fire, and must be practiced at all operational levels from the national fire director, state/regional director, and unit manager to employees in the field. ..." (emphasis added)
Source: Red Book (links above and below)
I will discuss the aspects of Risk Management, Standard Firefighting Orders and Watch Out Situations, LCES and the Downhill Line Construction Checklist in a future posting. Consider now the Red Book direction on Personnel Protective Equipment.
"Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) Required Fireline PPE"
"National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 1977 compliant long-sleeved flame resistant shirt (yellow recommended)" (emphasis added) So then, to a thinking WF or FF this implies that shirt sleeves must remain rolled down, (i.e. "long-sleeved flame resistant shirt") Chapter 7, p. 172
Therefore, is a Structure Protection Specialist - a leader - with his sleeves rolled up while on the firelines setting a good example? Is this the type of influence the Red Book speaks about? Is this an example of a good leader providing purpose, direction, and motivation for his WFs?
The alleged Millennials, Gen Alphabetters, etc. pick right up on this Double Standard attitude. "We work for them, and if they're not doing it (or doing it) then we don't have to do it (or can do it), whatever the case may be.
Consider reading this article from a former HS Supt. turned Safety Officer article titled: Fire Shirts for Safety, Not Fashion: Proper Use of PPE To Prevent Thermal Heat Burn Injuries. Fire Management Today, Vol. 73, No. 1 (2013) p. 36-40 by Fred J. Schoeffler
I will now examine leadership principles from the perspective of two former US Navy SEALS (Jocko Willink and Leif Babin) and bullets cited directly from their book titled Extreme Ownership: How U.S. Navy SEALs Lead and Win.
"Implementing Extreme Ownership requires checking your ego and operating with a high degree of humility. Admitting mistakes, taking ownership, and developing a plan to overcome challenges are integral to any successful team.”
“Extreme Ownership. Leaders must own everything in their world. There is no one else to blame. ... Take responsibility for leading everyone in your world subordinates and superiors alike. ... A leader must be attentive to details but not obsessed by them."
― Jocko Willink and Leif Babin (2015) Extreme Ownership: How U.S. Navy SEALs Lead and Win
Figure 1. Screenshot of Prescott FD (PFD) Wildland Battalion Chief (WBC) Darrell Willis wearing a wildland fire long-sleeved fire shirt with the left sleeve rolled up at marker seven seconds (video below) In the video it will be revealed that both sleeves are rolled up. He was the Structure Protection Specialist for the Double Bar A Ranch area on the YH Fire. Source: AZ State Forestry (AZSF) files
Figure 2. Screenshot of PFD WBC Darrell Willis wearing a wildland fire long-sleeved fire shirt with the right sleeve rolled up at marker six seconds in the video below. Source: AZSF files
Willis' wristwatch and wedding ring in the screenshots above certainly 'match' this other photo within the links below:
( https://editorial01.shutterstock.com/wm-preview-450/6205121i/b65d42ff/firefighters-killed-yarnell-usa-shutterstock-editorial-6205121i.jpg ) and ( https://youtu.be/YDQRLXZV1Ro )
Figure 3. PFD BC Cory Moser video, about 12:10 PM on June 30, 2013, at the Double-Bar-A Ranch area where PFD WBC Darrell Willis and his Task Force were doing structure protection work. All Moser videos of initial VLAT drops that day were filmed between 12:03 and 12:13 PM. Source: AZSF files
PFD WBC Willis is a leader in the Prescott FD and within the general fire industry. His rolled up shirt sleeves on the fireline do not meet the requirements set forth in National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 1977 standards referenced further below. His actions as a leader are contrary to established wildland fire leadership principles. And even though many WFs may consider it a minor infraction and of no real consequence, his actions fall well within the 'Normalization of Deviance' principles examined by 'The Challenger Launch Decision' author Diane Vaughan (1996, 2016). Vaughan described this principle as social normalization of deviance which means that people within the organization become so accustomed to a deviant behavior that they do not consider it as deviant, even though their actions go beyond their organizational safety rules (1996). In other words, "... they become more accustomed to the deviant behavior the more it occurs. "[Those] ... within the organization do not recognize the deviance because it is seen as a normal occurrence. ..." (1996). (emphasis added)
Consider now some published research on the Normalization of Deviance subject.
When Doing Wrong Feels So Right: Normalization of Deviance (2015) J. of Patient Safety
( https://www.researchgate.net/publication/273148155_When_Doing_Wrong_Feels_So_Right_Normalization_of_Deviance ) and Samudra Vijay ESD.83 Research Seminar in Engineering Systems 1 Book Review: The Challenger Launch Decision:Risky Technology, Culture, and Deviance at NASAAuthor: Diane Vaughan Publisher: University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London Publication Year: 1996 Review By: Samudra Vijay ( http://web.mit.edu/esd.83/www/notebook/The%20Challenger%20Launch%20Decision_1.pdf )
The PFD often speaks about the ambiguous "Prescott Way," so we need to ask ourselves if this is what they mean by that.
However, there is this: June 27, 2014 at 10:03 pm Frank Carrol stated over at Wildfire Today : "Kari Greer was castigated for taking photos of firefighters fighting fire with their sleeves rolled up." (emphasis added) So, that made me, the common civilian, think to myself 'oh yeah, Willis had his sleeves up in some video I have --- or was it instead --- what was up his sleeves?' Was it him (un)intentionally concealing videos/audios from that part of the day, June 30, 2013?
It is interesting to note that PFD Cory Moser was serving as a Type 3 Incident Line Safety Officer in a 2012 Annual Prescott Basin Spring Wildfire Drill training scenario. Hopefully, PFD BC Moser corrected his superior (Willis) on this safety matter at some point during the June 30, 2013 YH Fire.
What is interesting to note is that the Moser video provides evidence that Willis was taking either photos or a videos of the VLAT drops out there at the Double-Bar-A Ranch circa 12:10 PM. However, there is NO evidence of THESE photos and/or videos to the Serious Accident Investigation Team (SAIT). Whatever Willis is 'shooting' there in the Moser video does NOT appear in his 'Photos and Video' folder in the SAIT evidence Dropbox. (link provided) Yet I was able to retrieve them from among my voluminous AZ Public Record Requests.
So then, it begs the question of how many MORE photos and/or videos ( with possible audio, radio captures ) did Willis NOT pass on to the SAIT. Is this what they mean by "the Prescott Way"? The PFD Darrell Willis' folder is located in the SAIT evidence Dropbox at the link below.
Earlier in 2018, I snail mailed Willis the subject matter in this post that I would like to meet before putting the data out public, and I never heard back from him.
Figure 4. June 30, 2014, YouTube video about the GMHS (“Team of 12 had sacred task of recovering bodies of fallen hotshots” ABC 15 News Arizona) Source: YouTube - ABC15 News Arizona
The one speaking in the video is Prescott Fire Captain (PFC) from 1994 to 2015 J.P. Vicente (he is erroneously referred to as a Fire Chief in the video) He makes a bizarre statement from 2:23 to 2:32.
PFC J.P. Vicente, speaking about the GMHS, said: “They’re all heroes. And they did what they loved doing. They're all heroes? Only the Municipal FDs subscribe to the heroes ideology. In my view, a Wildland Fire "hero" is dead because they messed up somehow. Vincente said "AND THEY WOULD DO IT ALL OVER AGAIN IN A HEARTBEAT. I’M TELLING YOU RIGHT NOW. THEY WOULDN’T CHANGE A THING.” (2:23 to 2:32) This statement is truly baffling to the authors and most WFs and FFs. They would do it all over again ... in a heartbeat. What kind of a lessson is that?
Are you kidding me!? They would do it all over again in a heartbeat and would not change a thing! (sigh) This guy is not talking about them going out to the fatality site to respectfully deal with the bodies of these FFs. He is talking about being killed on the YH Fire. From what I remember that is the definition of insanity, doing the same things over and over expecting a different result.
These statements (above) by the PFD Captain are rather disturbing and seem to reveal a trend in the PFD attitude toward WF safety. During the July 2013 Fatality Site News Conference, PFD WBC Darrell Willis made similar comments regarding the PFD and the GMHS and their attitudes, beliefs, human factors, and ways of thinking about the WF and FF safety and structure protection dichotomy. Does this respectively and collectively reveal another facet of the Prescott Way?
Figure 5. GMHS co-founder and Prescott Wildland Division Chief Darrell Willis at the GMHS Deployment Site - Video Part 1. Published on Jul 24, 2013. Darrell Willis answers media questions where 19 members of his Crew died on June 30, 2013. Source: InvestigativeMEDIA John Dougherty
Figure 6. GMHS co-founder and Prescott Wildland Division Chief Darrell Willis at the GMHS Deployment Site - Video Part 2. Published on Jul 24, 2013. Darrell Willis answers media questions where 19 members of his Crew died on June 30, 2013. Source: InvestigativeMEDIA John Dougherty
Some say that Willis considered these men his sons, and so he was likely in some form of shock. I have a lot of empathy for the man, for the loss of his men. What I am questioning here is his leadership and his and the PFD safety attitude. These two videos are a must, especially for WF and FF supervisors, to better understand the alleged "Prescott Way" that the authors and many others consider as a causal factor in the final outcome. And as an experienced WF or FF, you should be squirming in your seats and maybe even cussing as you listen to and watch the video or read this here.
He made these following statements:
"... they were doing their work all day long (1:58) I was there. I disagree. When I saw them many times throughout that day, they were at a standstill or resting.
"... it was ten foot chaparral, very volatile fuel ..." (2:39) This comment was my very first reason why I reached out to Willis to correct him on that specific area, the box canyon. The truth of the matter is the chaparral was waist-high and NOT ten foot high as he claimed. I showed him my photos of the brush height of the same area before the men died on June 30, 2013.
Figure 7. Waist high Chaparral in what became the eventual GMHS Deployment Zone area and subsequent Fatality Site area. Photo taken the morning of June 30, 2013. This is a Snippet of Figure 58. from the November 3, 2018, Sonny Gilligan "How Many Lives ..." post. Source: Joy A. Collura
“ … they were in a safe location, they were not satisfied and no WF is satisfied sitting there and watching the fire progress without doing … taking some action …” (4:00) Once again, are you kidding me? There are literally tens of thousands of WFs and FFs on the firelines every year that would be more than happy to be in a Safety Zone watching the fire progress below without taking any action.
"... they started to move down that hill in that drainage (5:30)... just imagine having brush in that drainage ten foot high ... (5:46), ... the fire was totally blocked from their view, they can't see the fire over in that point, so they've committed to go downhill at this point ... at that point that's when things started to change dynamically ... (6:07), they were committed to go downhill. (6:35) ... they knew that they had fire on both sides of them, they knew they had fire behind them and now they had fire ahead of them.(6:45) ..."
That series of statements requires extreme scrutiny. Consider now and analyze what the PFD WBC says above:" ... they started to move down that hill in that drainage." Since when do WFs and FFs travel in unburned drainages (i.e. known dangerous chutes and chimneys)?
"just imagine having brush in that drainage ten foot high ..." Okay, let's imagine that. Now WTF are you doing in a drainage - in the unburned - in brush that is ten feet high? WTF!
"... the fire was totally blocked from their view, they can't see the fire over in that point" Okay, so very clear violations of he Fire Orders, such as Fire Order No. 2 (Know what your fire is doing at all times. Observe personally. Use scouts), Order No. 5 (post lookouts), and Watch Out No. 12 (Cannot see main fire, not in contact with anyone who can) Hindsight bias as "they" like to say? No way, how about basic, safe wildland firefighting.
"so they've committed to go downhill at this point ... at that point that's when things started to change dynamically ... , they were committed to go downhill. So then, according to PFD WBC justification, there was no 52 minutes from blow-up to burnover when the GMHS was "discussing our options," and no indications that this fire behavior was increasing before their eyes exponentially from the prime YH Fire vantage point, for their fatal downhill commitment. Willis' "when things started to change dynamically" is merely covering for his men. This one begs the question - they were committed to go downhill and even more covering for his men.
" ... they knew that they had fire on both sides of them, they knew they had fire behind them and now they had fire ahead of them." Bulls**t! Willis' statement is really one of the only places and times that this alleged "fact" is mentioned. See Figure 8. below and compare it with reality, at the Figure 8a. photo of June 30, 2013, at 1629 (4:29 PM) taken by ASF Brian Lauber of very aggressive fire behavior with no sign of any alleged "fire above."
Figure 8. Idealized image of alleged fire above and fire below. Source: SAIT-SAIR
Pure bulls**t, especially the the ten foot brush. WFs are trained that chutes and chimneys funnel strong winds and fire behavior and are very dangerous, in the Common Denominators. Fire Order No. 2 is know what your fire is doing at all times and LCES requires a lookout.
Figure 8a. June 30, 2013, 1629 (4:29 PM) photo taken by ASF Brain Lauber from the Ranch House restaurant along Hwy 89, revealing very aggressive fire behavior approaching the GMHS Deployment Zone (DZ).Google Earth overlay indicates GMHS location, mid-slope road, descent point, and GMHS DZ and BSR below. Source: ASF Lauber, Google Earth, WTKTT
Contnuing on with PFD WBC Willis' July 2013 News Conference interview analysis.
”I can tell you they died with honor. … a unique situation … they stuck together, … they saw and felt the same way ..." Clearly, the recognized hazardous attitude of Groupthink. The Prescott Way?
"I would have been with that Crew blindfolded,(12:11) they could have led me down here, I would have been with them, ..." Clearly, even more of the recognized hazardous attitude of Groupthink. More of the Prescott Way?
I had complete faith and confidence in the leadership … they would have never taken a risk they didn't think ... it's a risky business ... but they don't take undue risk ... very safety conscious, ..." Really? How about the several instances of the Normalization of Deviance and near misses they had on the 2012 Holloway Fire in NV, noted in this post and numerous other posts on this website.
"... and ah it's just one of those things that happened … you can call it an accident …I just say God had a different plan for that Crew at this time. ... one of the things they emphasize is [LCES]."
Really? Just one of those things that happened. Are you kidding me? You can call it an accident. Okay, that is such a relief. You mean nobody made any bad decisions at all? You have really drank the YHF and GMHS Kool-Aid if you really believe this emotional swill.
Several of these comments highly suggest many of the elements in the recognized hazardous attitude of Groupthink. ( http://www.au.af.mil/au/awc/awcgate/sam/groupthink_johnson.pdf )
When asked by one of the news media if the GMHS had specific rules to follow, he said “they [GMHS] emphasized ... (LCES), (13:19)… ,however, there are points during that workday that you don’t have that in place. They had a lookout, …(13:30) there are times when they are out here in this environment that you don't have all those standards in place especially with them moving like they were. You couldn’t leave anybody behind.“ (14:03) More bulls**t! You ALWAYS place a Lookout to comply with LCES. More of the Prescott Way maybe? That no lookout attitude occurred on the 2012 Holloway Fire when they had to quickly burn out around themselves and their Crew Carriers - TWO TIMES and had a Contract Fire Engine fire out around their Crew Carriers. This is based on Public Records and personal testimony from former GMHS Eric Naumetz (2011-2013) in a S-131 course at the AZ Fire Academy in Prescott.
LCES must ALWAYS be in place in order to fight the fire...REPEAT...always be in place; otherwise you are not suppose to engage the fire. So then, are all these included in the Prescott Way of fighting fire?
Webmaster reviewed page last: 7-19-18 1:45pm
Updates: minor spelling, punctuation, and grammar; caption spacing; established source links; clarification of PFD Wildland BC Willis' comments about LCES, primarily lookouts and safety zones; GMHS normalization of deviance regarding lookouts on the 2012 Holloway Fire, Bible scripture and comments on the mystical "Prescott Way," (June 27, 2021 at 12:40 PM)
Update: Added Douglas Fire as contributing author; more clarification on the PFD Cpt. Vincente "Team of 12 had sacred task of recovering bodies of fallen hotshots" video and GMHS Deployment Zone / Fatality Site News Conference comments; added Figure 8. and Figure 8a. depicting idealized SAIT-SAIR image and fire behavior photo; misc. minor bolding of text (June 28, 2021 at 3:28 PM)
Post Number Six
##wildlandfire #Yarnellfire #GraniteMountainHotShot #LCES #Fire Leadership #Safety and Risk Management and their Guiding Principles and Goal #Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and Required Fireline PPE #Safety and Risk Management #Implementing Extreme Ownership (hashtags)
© (All Rights Reserved) ( www.yarnellhillrevelations.com ) Disclaimer Copyright 2018
If you right click and click "print" and save as PDF- 14 pages.
Update October 5th, 2021, 12:58am- Fred J. Schoeffler has my full permission to use any and all content from "How does one effectively lead by example? Extreme ownership must apply ...?" on his new "Project 10 and 18 United" / "Project 10 and 18 International" blog he is creating.- Joy A. Collura
6-26-22 3:23pm Update: Home | Project 10 & 18 (project10n18.org)
Post Number One: Did the late afternoon, June 30, 2013, Sesame Street and The Shrine fire behavior/smoke plumes influ (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Number Two: Are These Possible Indications of YH Fire Burnout Ops In The Peeples Valley Area On June 30, 2013? (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Number Three:InvestigativeMEDIA Five (5) Years Later (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Number Four:What Lessons Have We Really Learned About The June 30, 2013, Yarnell Hill Fire? (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Number Five: Another Big Question Arises ... (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Number Seven: Will the fire community benefit from the ‘lessons learned’ concept and sustain a ‘safety culture’ wh (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post One: Fred John Schoeffler's Bio (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Two: Please Sign My Petition ... (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Three: Joy Ann Collura Bio- (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Six: InvestigativeMEDIA Five (5) Years Later (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Eight: https://www.yarnellhillfirerevelations.com/post/2018/07/04/another-big-question-arises